By Jennifer Fernandez
Key Takeaways:
- E-bike crashes involving children can cause severe injuries, including brain trauma, fractures and lengthy hospital stays.
- North Carolina’s new e-bike law lacks age limits and other safeguards, prompting a task force to consider recommendations for lawmakers.
- Lack of labeling makes it difficult for parents, police and health officials to identify e-bike types and assess risks.
At the Atrium Health Carolinas Medical Center, surgeon Hutton White has operated on more children with liver or spleen injuries, pelvic and femur fractures and traumatic brain injuries, all after they crashed on e-bikes.
Duke Hospital is seeing a rise in these injuries, too, Emily Greenwald, medical director for Duke’s pediatric emergency department, recently told members of the North Carolina Child Fatality Task Force.
These injuries are much more severe than what typically results from crashes involving pedal-only powered bicycles, the doctors have said. They look more like motorcycle crash injuries.
Greenwald said speed is part of the problem. E-bikes, which have an electric motor to help the rider pedal longer and go faster, can reach speeds up to 28 mph. That speed adds more energy when there’s a crash, intensifying injuries.
With traditional bicycles, speed and skill grow together over time, Greenwald said. But with e-bikes, young riders have a huge amount of speed available immediately. A motor lets young people go faster than their judgment or experience is equipped to handle, she said.
“We don’t let 14- and 12-year-olds drive cars because their frontal lobe is not developed enough to anticipate and have the sense of focus and attention that’s needed for a car to drive at a certain speed,” she said.
Even at the allowable e-bike speed of 20 mph, kids just aren’t ready, said Watts Dixon, owner of Revolution Cycles in Greensboro.
Revolution Cycles has serviced e-bikes for several years but has only been selling them for about two years, Dixon said. He’s definitely seen increased interest in them.
People like e-bikes because you can “sit and cruise” if you want to, Dixon said.
E-bikes can be a great tool, allowing people to commute to work, do chores and stay active longer, advocates said. With proper safety and limits, they can also help kids stay active, they argue.
But the safety risks have mounted quickly.
Members of the Child Fatality Task Force have spent more than three hours in committee meetings over the past two months discussing what should be done to make e-bikes safer for children. In December, they’ll review a slate of possible recommendations to pass on to state legislators when the General Assembly returns for next year’s legislative session.
They will likely ask legislators to consider:
- Adding age requirements for e-bike riders.
- Requiring manufacturers to label e-bikes with information on class, watts and maximum speed.
- Prohibiting alterations that would allow an e-bike to go faster than its classification allows.
- Prohibiting anyone from selling or advertising a non-e-bike, or an electric motorcycle, as an e-bike.
- Requiring helmets that are rated for the higher speeds of e-bikes.
- Restricting passengers on e-bikes operated by anyone under 18 years old.
“Just by the information and the discussion today, it is so evident that this is big time,” Martha Sue Hall, mayor pro tem of Albemarle City Council and a task force member, said at Wednesday’s meeting. “People want to do something.”

More work needed
A new North Carolina law goes into effect on Dec. 1 that creates three classifications of e-bicycles, based on maximum speed and pedal assist ability.
Under this law, North Carolina limits e-bicycles to 750 watts or lower. Class 1 e-bikes have pedal assist and no throttle, and the motor stops assisting at 20 mph. Class 2 can be propelled by a motor only with a throttle, but the motor stops assisting at 20 mph. Class 3 is pedal-assist only and the motor stops assisting at 28 mph.
The new law actually weakens protections for children, Kella Hatcher, executive director of the Child Fatality Task Force, told task force members.
The current law considers an electric-powered bicycle that can travel up to 28 mph a moped. Those can only be operated by someone 16 or older and must be registered and insured, she said.
“But next month, that exact same bike is going to be a Class 3 e-bike, and there’s no requirement for being age 16,” Hatcher said. “There’s no requirement for registration or insurance. So basically, 12-year-olds as of December 1st can ride what is essentially a moped.”
While the three-tier classification will mirror what other states are doing, North Carolina’s law doesn’t go far enough, task force members said.
The new law doesn’t have age restrictions, speed limits or restricted areas of use, Hatcher said. There’s no state requirement for helmet use for 16- or 17-year-olds on the Class 1 and 2 bikes.
North Carolina’s new regulations for e-bikes take effect on Dec. 1. The state is moving to a three-class e-bike system.
- Class 1: pedal assist, no throttle, motor stops assisting at 20 mph.
- Class 2: can be propelled by a motor only with a throttle, but the motor stops assisting at 20 mph.
- Class 3: pedal-assist only and motor stops assisting at 28 mph.
Riders under age 18 will be required to wear a helmet on Class 3 e-bikes. All riders under 16 must wear a helmet for any type of bicycle.
The new law also permits e-bikes in roads, bicycle lanes, greenways and multiuse paths. Municipalities can further regulate e-bikes, including restricting the use of certain classes, establishing speed limits and deciding whether they can be operated on multiuse paths or sidewalks.
North Carolina lacks any requirement for manufacturers and sellers to accurately describe bikes and their capabilities, nor does the state restrict anyone from modifying e-bikes to go faster than their classification allows.
“Several medical and safety organizations … have weighed in on this because they, like a lot of us in this state, are seeing this issue blow up,” Hatcher said.
The federal Consumer Product Safety Commission recommends that children aged 9 to 12 should not operate any device that goes faster than 10 mph.
Medical groups are getting involved in advocacy around limiting e-bike use among young people too. The American Academy of Pediatrics and Safe Kids Worldwide recommend that no children under age 12 ride e-bikes. Both groups say children aged 12 to 15 should only ride Class 1 e-bikes. They also say 16-year-olds should start with a Class 1 or 2 e-bike.
The American College of Surgeons last year recommended that policies be developed and enforced to categorize e-bikes based on speed and power, implement rider age restrictions, and mandate safety equipment such as helmets. The group also called for clearer guidelines for using e-bikes on roads and bike lanes to reduce conflicts with pedestrians and traditional cyclists.
E-bike regulations elsewhere
New York City is leading the way with regulating e-bikes because the popularity of the devices emerged early there, said Katie Harmon, senior health sciences research associate with the UNC Highway Safety Research Center.
New York City has clear definitions for e-bike classes and their operating characteristics. The city has also designated a separate e-moto (electric motorcycle) category for vehicles that can go faster than 25 mph, and it requires e-moto riders to be licensed.
Because the city has seen many dangerous crashes involving commercial e-bike users, such as delivery drivers, it is revising its enforcement approaches, she said. New York City is using public education campaigns and requiring commercial e-bike operators to get training, Harmon said.
Safe Kids Worldwide created a checklist to help families decide if a child is ready for an e-bike.
Hatcher said a majority of states don’t allow children under age 16 to use Class 3 e-bikes at all. Some have set minimum ages for riding any e-bike. Age limits differ by state.
Earlier this year, New Jersey expanded its e-bike regulations. Riders must now be at least 15 years old. All riders must be licensed, wear a helmet and register their bikes. Some riders also must have insurance.
Utah, Colorado and Oregon made it illegal to modify an e-bike to bypass the device that cuts motor assistance once a bike reaches a set speed, while New York State requires manufacturers to label devices, including e-scooters, in order to improve identification and enforcement.
That is a big problem in North Carolina, which does not require e-bikes to be labeled, task force members said.
“We don’t know what these devices are when they’re not labeled,” Hatcher said. “And that really challenges parents, it challenges law enforcement, it challenges everybody with understanding what kind of device is this.”

Enforcement issues
Mark Ezzell, who recently retired as director of the Governor’s Highway Safety Program, reached out to local law enforcement to get their take on e-bike use in their communities.
According to the information that he shared with Hatcher, law enforcement said they’re seeing a huge increase in problems with e-bikes, and much of it is involving kids under 16.
Sgt. Santana Menard, an investigator with the Reidsville Police Department and task force member, said she has had many complaints about e-bikes, including people being run off the sidewalks by them.
Law enforcement told Ezell that it’s difficult to deal with because the state doesn’t have specific laws related to youth and e-bikes.

The law enforcement personnel said they’d like to see minimum age requirements for the higher-powered devices, along with better helmet laws.
They also said that it is hard to differentiate what classes e-bikes fall under and said it is difficult to measure speed on them.
It can be difficult to pursue charges in cases involving youth because laws around e-bikes are limited, Menard said. Many times, officers instead have to charge the parent with contributing to the delinquency of a minor.
Task force members discussed whether education about safety, and new laws if they are implemented, might be a better route.
“There could be an avenue to treat this in a way that some of the diversion programs have worked with our child passenger safety seats,” said Tricia Smar, adult injury prevention coordinator at Duke Trauma Center.
Smar noted a lot of people who have violated the state’s child seat safety laws get sent to diversion.
“They get that education, and then they’re better off for it when their kid is safer,” Smar said. “I think there are ways that we could make it more about education instead of necessarily punitive, based on what else we have done.”
Crash data incomplete
As e-bikes have risen in popularity, so have crashes involving them. Many of those injured are children who are coming into contact more often with motor vehicles than when they’re riding pedaled bicycles, White said.
“We’re seeing lots of skull fractures, brain bleeds, bleeding in and around the brain,” he said. “We’ve had kids need craniectomies, where they go in and remove a portion of their skull to allow the brain to swell.
“This can be devastating on their brain development, and it can affect their memory and their attention and their ability to learn.”
Some children end up in the ICU for several days with a ventilator to help them breathe, he said. They may be hospitalized for weeks and need months of physical therapy.
By comparison, when kids on a regular bicycle get injured, it is typically one injury — a broken arm or leg, White said.
“They may need one operation, and then they often go home in a day or two, and they’re normally back to normal in a couple weeks,” he said.
Greenwald said kids are more vulnerable to e-bike and e-moto crashes because they have bigger heads and their bones tend to be more pliable.
“All of that [crash] energy goes through to their internal organs,” she said. “Whereas, once you get older, your bones just break, and that sort of absorbs some of the force and actually protects your internal organs sometimes.”
Many of the crashes are likely due to electric motorcycles, which can go more than 40 mph, Greenwald said. But it is difficult to tell these devices apart, so hospital data only indicates “e-bike” — if that information is available at all, she said.
Harmon said it’s “almost impossible to disentangle” e-bikes from e-motos under the injury codes, making it hard to really get a handle on e-bike injuries. The codes were developed before health professionals realized that e-motos would become so heavily used on roads, she said. Added to that, in most jurisdictions, including North Carolina, single-vehicle wrecks involving e-bikes often don’t get reported to police.
“There’s going to be no corresponding crash report that ends up with our crash data, which is what we often use to make traffic safety decisions in our state,” Harmon said.
Again, New York City again is leading the way, she said. The city has expanded its crash reporting to include e-bike and pedal-cycle incidents that do not involve motor vehicles, Harmon said.
Since it is so hard to differentiate e-bikes based on their looks, Greenwald said North Carolina will “have to figure out how to increase safety all around.”

